Confused !!!

I'm so confused on what I have to do next! I have this amazing bf who loves me and treats me right. & I know I can always count on him for anything. But then theres him.. The guy from my story! He knows me better than anyone else, how? I don't even know. But he does! && he's there for me too. Yesterday I made dinner for both off us after work. Then I had to go to my aunts, && out of no where I get a text from him thanking me for making dinner! He actually appreciated it ;) but then I haven't talked to my bf, which makes me upset because I feel like he's not trying! Ughh idk what to do I have two amazing guys! Please if anyone ... Help??!